The Truth About Kitchen Material Costs: When to Spend and When to Save

Planning a kitchen remodel can be exciting—but also overwhelming, especially when it comes to budgeting. One of the biggest challenges homeowners face is deciding where to invest in premium materials and where it’s okay tocut back without compromising quality. At Property Essentials, we help homeowners throughout Southern Maine—from Wells to Kennebunkport—make smart, informed decisions that balance aesthetics, performance, and budget.

In this guide, we break down the key materials used in kitchen remodels and offer expert insight on when it makes sense to splurge—and when saving won’t hurt your long-term satisfaction.

1. Countertops: Spend Smartly

Your countertops take a beating daily, so durability and ease of maintenance are key. This is one area where investing a bit more upfront can pay off in the long run.

• Spend On: Quartzite, quartz, or honed granite. These are durable, resistant to stains and heat, and elevate the look of your kitchen.

  • Example: Cambria quartz surfaces or Mont Lucia quartzite.

• Save On: Laminate or butcher block (in smaller areas like a coffee bar or island prep zone). These can still offer a high-end look when used strategically.

Verdict: Prioritize performance on your main prep surfaces; save on accent areas.

2. Cabinetry: Invest Where It Counts

Cabinets make up the largest visual (and functional) footprint in your kitchen. Custom cabinetry provides tailored storage solutions and longevity that mass-produced boxes can’t match.

• Spend On: Lower cabinets and island cabinetry where durability and storage efficiency matter most. Opt for solid wood frames and soft-close hardware.

• Save On: Upper cabinets or pantry shelving. Consider semi-custom lines or open shelving to reduce costs without sacrificing style.

Verdict: Invest in the areas that get the most use; you’ll feel the difference every day.

3. Flooring: Save—But Don’t Cheap Out

Flooring takes abuse from foot traffic, spills, and dropped pans. While you can save by not going ultra-luxury, be careful not to go too cheap either.

• Spend On: Engineered hardwood or luxury vinyl plank (LVP) with a high wear rating. These offer durability, water resistance, and a high-end appearance.

• Save On: Skip real hardwood if your kitchen is prone to spills or high humidity. Some LVP brands (like Coretec or Karndean) look like hardwood without the price tag.

Verdict: Look for value-driven durability. LVP and engineered options can deliver beauty without busting your budget

4. Backsplashes: Save with Style

Backsplashes don’t face the same daily wear as other materials, which means you can often get creative without breaking the bank.

• Spend On: Statement materials in focal areas—like the range wall. Natural stone or handmade tile can become a kitchen’s showpiece.

• Save On: Subway tile, ceramic mosaics, or peel-and-stick tile for accent walls or behind small appliances.

Verdict: Use bold materials sparingly to make a big impact for less

5. Appliances: Spend Strategically

Appliances should align with how you use your kitchen. You don’t need a commercial-grade setup unless you’re hosting gourmet dinners every week.

• Spend On: The range or cooktop—especially if you’re an avid home chef. Induction, gas, or dual-fuel ranges from Wolf or Thermador offer serious cooking power.

• Save On: Microwaves, secondary ovens, or drawer-style dishwashers. Mid-tier brands like Whirlpool or Bosch still offer performance at a lower price point.

Verdict: Upgrade the tools you use the most. Everything else can be mid-range without sacrificing quality

Final Thoughts: Your Kitchen, Your Priorities

Every kitchen remodel is unique, and your priorities should guide where your dollars go. If you love to cook, invest in appliances and prep surfaces. If you entertain often, splurge on lighting and statement finishes. Our team at Property Essentials can help you determine where to spend and where to save—without compromising your vision.

Ready to Plan a Smart Kitchen Remodel?

Serving homeowners in Wells, Kennebunk, Kennebunkport, Ogunquit, and across Southern Maine, Property Essentials brings craftsmanship, transparency, and design expertise to every remodel. Let’s create a kitchen that reflects your style, suits your lifestyle, and stays within budget.

Contact us today to start planning your dream kitchen with confidence.

Contact Us

Property Essentials proudly serves homeowners across Southern Maine’s coastal communities, including Wells, Kennebunk, Kennebunkport, Ogunquit, York, and Cape Neddick. We specialize in high-end kitchen remodels, luxury bathroom renovations, custom builds, and large-scale additions designed to enhance both lifestyle and long-term value. If you’re searching for a trusted coastal Maine contractor with a reputation for craftsmanship, design expertise, and professionalism, our team is here to guide your project from concept to completion.